Skip to content
Compare destinations

Which is better: Fernando de Noronha or Ilhabela?

Short answer

Fernando de Noronha is in the state of Pernambuco (PE), while Ilhabela is on the North Coast of São Paulo (SP): different regions of Brazil. Fernando de Noronha: a volcanic archipelago in the middle of the Atlantic where the water is so clear it hardly seems real, and Baía do Sancho was once voted the best beach in the world; Ilhabela: Brazil's largest marine island, reachable only by ferry. For this month's weather, Fernando de Noronha has the edge.

Sources: INMET (updated 2026) · ANP · OpenStreetMap
Most reviewed activity in Fernando de NoronhaFernando de Noronha Island Tour★ 9.9 · 18 reviews · from US$ 68 · via CivitatisSee dates and price →
Most reviewed activity in IlhabelaSnorkeling Class in Ilhabela★ 10 · 12 reviews · from US$ 26 · via CivitatisSee dates and price →
Fernando de Noronha Ilhabela
Best time to visit Sep → Dec May → Aug
Weather this month 30° · 3 days of rain 26° · 15 days of rain
By car by air only R$ 132 · from São Paulo
Ideal stay 4–5 days 4–5 days
Best for Romantic, Adventure, Relax Adventure, Relax, Romantic, Family
Choose Fernando de Noronha if

you want a trip for couples and adventure seekers: a volcanic archipelago in the middle of the Atlantic where the water is so clear it hardly seems real, and Baía do Sancho was once voted the best beach in the world.

See guide
Choose Ilhabela if

you want a trip for adventure seekers and relaxation: sailing, shipwreck dives, waterfalls in the forest and the dreaded borrachudo.

See guide
Comparison tool
Compare Fernando de Noronha and Ilhabela with any other destination
Build your own side-by-side table with up to 3 destinations.
Open the comparison tool
Where to stay

Where to stay: Fernando de Noronha or Ilhabela

The average nightly rate is around R$ 1,317 in Fernando de Noronha and R$ 320 in Ilhabela; what changes in practice is each place's season. Check current prices for your dates before deciding.

Compare hotels and places to stay in Fernando de Noronha on Booking.com, with up-to-date prices and availability, before you book.

Beco Pousada Boutique in Fernando de Noronha 9.5 ★★ · 46 reviews Beco Pousada Boutique See on Booking → Pousada Lua Bela in Fernando de Noronha 9.4 ★★★★ · 2 reviews Pousada Lua Bela See on Booking →
See all hotels in Fernando de Noronha

Compare hotels and places to stay in Ilhabela on Booking.com, with up-to-date prices and availability, before you book.

See all hotels in Ilhabela

Rates change with the dates: confirm the price on Booking.com.

Frequently asked questions

Fernando de Noronha or Ilhabela: which is better?
Fernando de Noronha is in the state of Pernambuco (PE), while Ilhabela is on the North Coast of São Paulo (SP): different regions of Brazil. Fernando de Noronha: a volcanic archipelago in the middle of the Atlantic where the water is so clear it hardly seems real, and Baía do Sancho was once voted the best beach in the world; Ilhabela: Brazil's largest marine island, reachable only by ferry. For this month's weather, Fernando de Noronha has the edge.
What is the best time to visit Fernando de Noronha and Ilhabela?
The best time to visit Fernando de Noronha is from September to December; for Ilhabela, it is from May to August, based on INMET's climate normals (temperature and rainfall for each month). If your trip already has a date, check each destination's page for your month.
Where does it rain less, Fernando de Noronha or Ilhabela?
Averaged over the year, Fernando de Noronha has 9 rainy days a month and Ilhabela has 13. Fernando de Noronha is the drier of the two over the year as a whole, but what decides the trip is the month: the rainiest month in Fernando de Noronha is April and in Ilhabela, January. For temperature, Fernando de Noronha is the warmer one (average high of 30° versus 27°).
How many days should you spend in Fernando de Noronha and in Ilhabela?
To see the main sights without rushing, Fernando de Noronha calls for 4–5 days and Ilhabela, 4–5 days. These are distant regions: with a week or less, it is usually better to pick one of the two and make the most of it.
Fernando de Noronha or Ilhabela with kids?
Ilhabela (national capital of sailing, shipwreck diving, and waterfalls in the forest) is the better pick of the two for families. Fernando de Noronha (best beach in the world, breathtaking diving, and preserved paradise) is geared more toward adults or couples. With small children, weather matters: Fernando de Noronha has fewer rainy days over the year.
What should you not miss in each?
In Fernando de Noronha: Baía do Sancho, Baía dos Porcos, Praia do Leão. In Ilhabela: Castelhanos Beach, Cachoeira da Toca, Vila and historic center. These are the sights that show up most in first-trip itineraries for each destination; the full guide to each has the whole list.